New York ran its own surprise-bill dispute process for years before the federal No Surprises Act existed. It still governs a large share of out-of-network disputes in the state. Filing a New York claim federally, or a federal claim with New York, is one of the most common reasons disputes get thrown out.
Recent change: amendments signed on May 28, 2026 took effect for disputes filed on or after August 26, 2026. They are summarized below. Disputes filed earlier follow the previous rules.
At a glance
| New York IDR | |
|---|---|
| Administered by | Department of Financial Services (DFS) |
| Covers | Surprise bills and bills for emergency services |
| Plans | Fully insured coverage regulated by New York, the NYS Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan |
| Not covered | Self-funded employer or union plans (federal process), and Medicaid Managed Care for disputes filed on or after May 28, 2026 |
| Decision | The IDR entity selects either the provider’s fee or the plan’s payment |
| Decision deadline | 45 business days from receiving all needed information (disputes filed on or after Aug. 26, 2026) |
| Fees | Both parties pay the IDR entity when the dispute is submitted; refunds follow the determination |
Which claims go through New York’s process
New York’s process covers two kinds of out-of-network claim:
- Emergency services, and
- Surprise bills: services from an out-of-network provider at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center, or services the patient was referred to by an in-network doctor.
The deciding question is the patient’s coverage:
- Fully insured coverage regulated by New York: the member ID card will say “fully insured”. This goes to the New York process.
- The NYS Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan (SUNY/CUNY graduate and teaching assistants) go to the New York process for disputes filed on or after August 26, 2026.
- Self-funded employer or union coverage generally goes to the federal IDR process. See our federal IDR timeline.
- Medicaid Managed Care disputes filed on or after May 28, 2026 are excluded from New York IDR.
For more on how to tell the processes apart, see Federal vs. state IDR.
How to file
- Get a case number through the DFS Portal. First-time users create a portal account and request access to the NY IDR application.
- Complete the IDR Provider and Insurer Application.
- Send the application to the assigned IDR entity, together with the full IDR fee for that entity.
What changed for disputes filed on or after August 26, 2026
- Payment upfront. Both the provider and the plan must pay the IDR entity in full when the dispute is submitted. The entity issues any refund within 30 days of its determination.
- More time for decisions. IDR entities have 45 business days from receiving all the information they need, up from 30.
- State plans added. The Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan now use the New York process, with their own decision standard: the entity selects whichever amount is closer to a benchmark set at the 50th percentile of allowed amounts.
- No double-dipping. A dispute involving a State Plan can’t be brought in New York if it already received a federal IDR decision or is pending in the federal process.
- Situations where no fee is awarded. The IDR entity can’t award the provider’s fee if the plan shows an existing contract covering the services, or proper prior-authorization notice that the services were out-of-network.
DFS adopted implementing regulations on an emergency basis while the permanent version goes through public comment. Expect further refinements.
Practical takeaways
- Check the ID card first. “Fully insured” means New York. A self-funded plan usually means federal.
- Budget for upfront fees. Under the 2026 rules, filing ties up cash until the determination and refund.
- Allow for the longer decision window when forecasting cash flow on New York disputes.
- Keep federal and state filings separate for State Plan claims. A claim can’t run in both.
Sources
- NY DFS: How to Dispute a Surprise Medical Bill
- NY DFS Insurance Circular Letter No. 5 (2026)
- NY DFS press release, August 13, 2026
General information, not legal advice. Rules change; confirm current requirements with DFS before filing.