New Jersey’s Out-of-Network Consumer Protection, Transparency, Cost Containment and Accountability Act set up binding arbitration for out-of-network payment disputes in 2018. It runs on a strict sequence of 30-day windows. Missing any one of them can permanently bar arbitration of the claim.
At a glance
| New Jersey OON arbitration | |
|---|---|
| Administered by | Department of Banking and Insurance (DOBI) |
| Covers | Inadvertent and/or involuntary out-of-network services, including emergency and urgent care |
| Plans | Health benefits plans issued in New Jersey, and self-funded plans that opt in |
| Minimum dispute | $1,000 difference between the final offers |
| Decision | Baseball-style: the arbitrator picks one final offer |
| Decision deadline | 30 days after a complete application |
| Cost | Split between the parties, unless the carrier didn’t act in good faith |
Which claims qualify
The process applies to inadvertent and/or involuntary out-of-network services:
- emergency or urgent care, and
- inadvertent services: an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility when in-network services weren’t available, and certain lab testing ordered by an in-network provider.
It does not apply to voluntary out-of-network care, where the patient knowingly chose an out-of-network provider. It also excludes care provided through an in-plan exception, and disputes about medical necessity, experimental treatment or cosmetic services.
Plans covered: plans issued in New Jersey, for services provided in New Jersey by New Jersey-licensed providers. Out-of-state plans and federal plans, including Managed Medicaid, are excluded.
Self-funded plans may opt in. An opted-in plan’s ID card will say “NJ arbitration – YES”. Self-funded plans that haven’t opted in typically fall under the federal IDR process.
The sequence of deadlines
- Carrier’s initial payment. Within 20 days of receiving the claim, the carrier either pays billed charges or pays its initial allowed amount. The remittance must explain your right to negotiate.
- Reject within 30 days. If you don’t accept the initial allowed amount as payment in full, notify the carrier within 30 days of receiving that notice. Carriers must accept certified mail, email and online submission. If you don’t respond in time, you lose the right to arbitrate.
- Negotiate for 30 days. The negotiation period runs 30 days from the carrier’s notice.
- Carrier’s final offer. If negotiation fails, the carrier sends its final offer and reprocesses the claim.
- File for arbitration within 30 days of receiving the carrier’s final offer. Late applications are rejected.
Filing and the decision
- The difference between the two final offers must be at least $1,000. Claims can be combined for the same patient receiving multiple services from the same provider during the same admission or emergency event.
- The arbitration vendor acknowledges the application within seven business days and flags any deficiencies. They must be corrected within 15 days, or the application is treated as withdrawn.
- The arbitrator issues a written decision within 30 days of receiving a complete application. The decision must select either the provider’s or the carrier’s final offer.
- Costs are split between the parties, unless the carrier is found not to have acted in good faith. Legal fees aren’t awarded.
- If the provider wins, the carrier must pay the difference within 20 days. Late payments accrue 12% annual interest.
Practical takeaways
- Treat the first 30-day window as critical. A missed rejection notice can’t be fixed later.
- Check the ID card on self-funded plans for “NJ arbitration – YES”.
- Aggregate where allowed to clear the $1,000 threshold on smaller claims.
Sources
- NJ DOBI Bulletin 18-14: Out-of-Network Consumer Protection Act implementation
- NJ DOBI: Out-of-network consumer protections
General information, not legal advice. Confirm current requirements with DOBI and its arbitration vendor before filing.