Georgia’s Surprise Billing Consumer Protection Act (O.C.G.A. § 33-20E) gives out-of-network providers and facilities a state arbitration process, run through the Office of Commissioner of Insurance. Several deadlines were lengthened in 2023. Older guides that cite 30-day windows are out of date.
At a glance
| Georgia surprise billing arbitration | |
|---|---|
| Administered by | Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance |
| Covers | Emergency services, and certain non-emergency services at in-network facilities |
| Plans | State-regulated plans only. ERISA self-funded plans are dismissed. |
| Filing deadline | 60 days from receipt of the insurer’s payment |
| Negotiation period | 60 days from the Commissioner receiving the request |
| Decision | Baseball-style, within 60 days of referral |
| Cost | Loser pays the arbitrator’s fees and expenses |
How the insurer must pay first
For out-of-network emergency services, Georgia requires insurers to pay the greater of:
- the verifiable contracted amount paid by all eligible insurers for the same or similar services, as determined by the department,
- the most recent amount agreed between the insurer and the provider when the provider was in-network, or
- a higher amount the insurer considers appropriate given the complexity and circumstances of the services.
Insurer payments must disclose whether the plan is subject to ERISA. That tells you whether the claim can use Georgia’s process at all.
Filing a request
- File within 60 days of receiving the insurer’s payment, and send the insurer a copy at the same time.
- Explain in detail why arbitration is needed. If the insurer’s payment followed the statutory formula, show the complexity and circumstances of the services that justify more.
- A request can cover:
- one patient and one service,
- one patient and multiple services,
- multiple patients and one service, or
- multiple substantially similar services in the same specialty across multiple patients.
The Commissioner must dismiss requests involving plans not regulated by the state, including ERISA self-funded plans. Those claims generally belong in the federal IDR process. The Commissioner may dismiss late requests, requests without the required explanation, and requests from providers with a pattern of not responding to the department or not paying arbitration organizations.
From request to decision
- Insurer data (within 60 days). The insurer must give the Commissioner the data needed to check its payment against the statute. Failing to do so can lead to penalties or a default judgment.
- Negotiation (60 days). The parties have 60 days from the Commissioner’s receipt of the request to settle, or to agree that they need more time.
- Referral. If there’s no settlement or extension, the Commissioner refers the dispute to a resolution organization within five days.
- Arbitrator selection (5 days). The parties can jointly choose an arbitrator. Otherwise the resolution organization appoints one.
- Final offers (10 days). Each side submits a final offer with written argument of up to 20 pages. The arbitrator may request one additional submission of up to 10 pages.
- Decision (within 60 days of referral). The arbitrator picks one of the two offers and can’t modify it. The decision considers the complexity and circumstances of the case, including the training, education and experience of the clinicians. It is binding and can’t be appealed in court.
Who pays
The party whose offer is not selected pays:
- the award amount,
- the arbitrator’s fees and expenses, and
- any resolution organization fees.
Payment is due within 15 days of the decision. That makes Georgia’s process attractive for strong claims and costly for weak ones.
Practical takeaways
- Read the ERISA disclosure on the remittance before choosing a forum.
- Make the complexity case in writing at filing. It’s a filing requirement, not just advocacy.
- Screen claims hard. Under loser-pays, weak claims cost real money.
Sources
General information, not legal advice. Confirm current requirements with the Georgia Office of Commissioner of Insurance before filing.