California’s AB 72 (2016) protects patients from surprise bills for non-emergency services from non-contracting providers at in-network facilities. It also sets up a binding independent dispute resolution process (IDRP) for payment disputes. For plans regulated by the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC), that process is run through a web portal by the independent organization DMHC contracts with.
At a glance
| California AB 72 IDRP (DMHC) | |
|---|---|
| Covers | Non-emergency services by non-contracting individual health professionals at, or resulting from care at, a contracting facility |
| Not covered | Emergency services, dentists, Medi-Cal managed care plans, and plans regulated by another state |
| Prerequisite | The plan’s Provider Dispute Resolution (PDR) process, completed within the last 365 days |
| Bundling | Up to 50 claims: same or similar services, same provider, same plan |
| Decision | Within 30 calendar days |
| Fees | $315–$415 per review, split equally |
The default reimbursement rate
Unless the provider and plan agree otherwise, the plan must pay the greater of:
- the average contracted rate: the claims-weighted average of the plan’s contracted commercial rates for the same or similar services in the region, calculated from two years before the year of service, or
- 125% of Medicare fee-for-service for the same or similar services in the region.
The IDRP is where either side can argue that this amount was wrong for a particular claim.
Eligibility
A dispute qualifies only if all of the following are true:
- it’s for non-emergency services, and there’s no unresolved dispute over whether the service was an emergency,
- the services were covered, and provided at, or as a result of care at, a contracting facility by a non-contracting individual health professional,
- the provider completed the plan’s PDR process within the last 365 days,
- the provider isn’t a dentist, and
- the payer isn’t a Medi-Cal managed care plan.
Late-payment disputes, interest disputes, medical-necessity denials and disputes about the level of care are not eligible.
If you filed a PDR but got no acknowledgment or decision after 45 business days, dated proof of the attempt can take the place of a determination letter.
Filing
Submit through the AB 72 IDRP portal, in PDF:
- the claim form(s),
- the PDR determination letter(s), or proof of the PDR attempt, and
- the EOB(s) or remittance advice.
You can’t revise an application after you submit it, so get it right the first time. You’re responsible for redacting protected health information that isn’t needed, and details of claims not in dispute. Once filed, the other party must participate.
How the reviewer decides
The independent organization has up to 30 calendar days and considers:
- the provider’s training, qualifications and length of time in practice,
- the nature of the services,
- the provider’s usual fees,
- prevailing provider rates in the geographic area,
- other relevant economics of the practice, and
- any unusual circumstances.
Unlike federal IDR, the reviewer isn’t limited to either party’s proposed amount. It sets the appropriate reimbursement by billing code. The decision is binding, but afterward a dissatisfied party may still pursue other remedies available under law.
Fees
Review fees are split equally and collected before review begins:
| Claims bundled | Standard | With coding review |
|---|---|---|
| 1–10 | $315 | $330 |
| 11–25 | $340 | $355 |
| 26–50 | $395 | $415 |
Emergency services and federal IDR
AB 72 IDRP doesn’t cover emergency services. Emergency claims, and claims under self-funded plans that California law doesn’t reach, need separate analysis. Many will belong in the federal IDR process. Insurers regulated by the California Department of Insurance have a parallel AB 72 process. Confirm which regulator oversees the plan before filing.
Practical takeaways
- Run PDR first, and file within 365 days of completing it.
- Bundle up to 50 similar claims to cut the per-claim cost.
- Build the file on the listed factors. Since the reviewer can set its own number, evidence matters more than offer strategy.
Sources
- DMHC: Non-Emergency Services Independent Dispute Resolution Process
- California Health and Safety Code § 1371.31
General information, not legal advice. Confirm current requirements with DMHC or the California Department of Insurance before filing.